We seem to be living in a moment when greed has taken hold of a
large segment of the population. There have been times in history
when self-sacrifice was prized. At other times banding together
for a common goal was admired. President Kennedy said "Ask not
what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your
country." Why the change in values?
Obviously greed has always existed and has been considered an
undesirable trait or even a "sin". Now public figures are
unashamed to make pronouncements like "Greed is good". Here are
several possible reasons.
We live in a secular age. In spite of the large amount of public
acknowledgment paid to religion it does not influence behavior
the way it did in past ages. The growth of scientific knowledge
has led to greater understanding of how the universe works and
even the faithful know in their innermost hearts that the
historical pictures of the afterlife no longer seem as possible.
As a consequence people are more focused on the here and now
rather than the hereafter. With only one chance on earth, "get as
much as you can" becomes more important than self denial in the
hopes of a better afterlife. So fear of death and the aftermath
motivates people to drown out their feelings with the pursuit of
wealth and material possessions. If you keep running fast enough
maybe you can bury your fears in incessant activity.
Simultaneously life has become more uncertain. Large changes in
the organization of society have left people fearful about their
social status in the future. Not only job insecurity, but health
insecurity and old age insecurity leave people worried. Getting a
large nest egg seems to be the best way to insulate against risk.
And once you start to worry about economic security how much is
Will we have a future like Weimar Germany with people carrying
money in wheelbarrows because of uncontrolled inflation? In
recent memory interest rates reached 13% in the US. What happens
to your nest egg then? Since there is no way to anticipate, no
amount of wealth can guarantee true security.
Fearful attitudes lead to a self-centered view of life.
Protection of the self replaces community cooperation. People
become less willing to contribute to the common good since even
that portion of their wealth might be hoarded. The consequence is
an unwillingness to support government projects and the related
taxation. What good does a higher school tax do me when I don't
have any children in school anymore? Or why pay for a park when I
People lose sight of the fact that there is some other social
good that they favor that is covered by taxes. Perhaps a road
improvement or more policing. The social contract between the
populace and the government has become weakened. If the promise
of old age and health security was restored people's underlying
generosity would then return and selfishness and greed would
Moral: Secure citizens are generous
Click here to see all my essays in context.
If you have any comments you would like to add email me at email@example.com
Copyright © 2004 Robert D Feinman
Feel free to use the ideas, but the words are mine.